The campaign outings of President Bola Tinubu and his party’s chieftains at the state and local government levels have largely been characterised by a disturbing absence of substantive policy discussions
By Emeka Alex Duru
Every election cycle in Nigeria brings renewed attempts at political intolerance and efforts to shrink the democratic space. The objective is often to weaken or eliminate opposition through various means. The 2027 election season is already witnessing similar tendencies.
A few days ago, the Kaduna State Government was reported to have withdrawn an earlier approval granted to the African Democratic Congress (ADC) to use the Ranchers Bees Stadium for a political rally. A statement attributed to Mohammed Sani Haruna, Senior Special Assistant to the Commissioner for Local Government and Chieftaincy Affairs, reportedly linked the decision to renovation work at the facility.
The ADC, however, insisted on proceeding with its programme, even if it meant holding the rally on the streets. The Commissioner, Sadiq Mamman Lagos, subsequently denied issuing the circular, describing it as fake.
In Enugu, the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) alleged that it was denied access to the Amadeo Event Centre, which it had booked for its rally, shortly before the scheduled event. The party accused Governor Peter Mbah of orchestrating the development. Mbah denied the allegation, arguing that he had no control over the privately owned facility.
The NDC also levelled similar allegations against the Federal Government, claiming that some hotels in Abuja had cancelled previously agreed arrangements for the party to use their facilities.
Earlier in the month, the ADC had complained that the Sokoto State Government denied its members access to venues and hotel accommodation during a visit by its presidential candidate, Atiku Abubakar.
All the governments accused by the opposition have denied the allegations. Perhaps their explanations are justified. Perhaps not. Whatever the case, the denials do not diminish concerns about the growing culture of political intolerance and insensitivity that appears to be taking root under the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) and its leaders.
Beyond the alleged denial of venues and other facilities to opposition parties is the increasing resort to hate speech, inflammatory rhetoric and name-calling as major features of APC campaigns at all levels.
Apart from occasional policy pronouncements by the NDC presidential candidate, Peter Obi, and his ADC counterpart, Atiku Abubakar, the campaign outings of President Bola Tinubu and his party’s chieftains at the state and local government levels have largely been characterised by a disturbing absence of substantive policy discussions.
The danger in this trend is enormous. If the President and his party continue along this path, intemperate language could gradually become the dominant medium of political communication in the country. No democracy can make meaningful progress under such an absurd political culture.
Beyond intimidating citizens with verbal aggression, the tendency could also influence voters to enter polling booths and cast their ballots for candidates who have no clearly articulated programmes of action. When that happens, the very essence of elections as opportunities for policy evaluation, democratic renewal and the renewal or withdrawal of political mandates is undermined.
I was not old enough to vote during the Second Republic in 1979. However, by 1983, I had attained voting age. In those days, it was common for young people like us to visit Enyimba Stadium in Aba, Abia State, or Orlu Township Stadium in Imo State, to listen to politicians articulate their programmes and explain how their respective parties intended to implement their manifestoes.
It was an exciting experience watching Nnamdi Azikiwe (Great Zik) of the Nigerian Peoples Party (NPP), Obafemi Awolowo (Awo) of the Unity Party of Nigeria (UPN), Aminu Kano of the Peoples Redemption Party (PRP), Waziri Ibrahim of the Great Nigerian Peoples Party (GNPP) and Shehu Shagari of the National Party of Nigeria (NPN) present their visions for the country.
Their lieutenants, including Chuba Okadigbo, Ibrahim Tahir and Nnia Nwodo for the NPN; Patrick Dele-Cole and Onyebor Obi for the NPP; and Ebenezer Babatope and Melie Chukelu Kafundu (MCK) Ajuluchukwu for the UPN, also helped to amplify their parties’ policy positions and programmes.
It was an era of serious political engagement, intellectual exchanges, witty arguments and occasional jibes at opponents. The supremacy of party ideology and manifestoes remained central to political contests.
Sadly, that period appears to have disappeared. With the emergence of President Olusegun Obasanjo in 1999, a political culture that gradually weakened party discipline and democratic safeguards became entrenched. Yet, at no time has the quality of political campaigns and debates deteriorated to such a troubling level as under the current Tinubu administration.
With the President’s apparent reluctance or inability to engage opponents in rigorous policy debates, political campaigns have increasingly descended into exchanges reminiscent of a marketplace. Throwing tantrums and hurling insults at opponents have become more prominent than addressing critical national issues with the seriousness and depth that campaign platforms ordinarily demand.
In the absence of robust ideas and coherent political arguments, bizarre directives and controversial rhetoric easily take centre stage.
One such example was Tinubu’s widely criticised admonition during the build-up to the 2023 general elections that political power was not meant to be served on a platter but had to be seized and taken away. The implications of that statement became a subject of intense public debate following his emergence as President in an election whose outcome was challenged by opposition parties.
Its political undertones were also reflected in subsequent state elections, where allegations of violence and intimidation by political thugs against opposition candidates and supporters were repeatedly reported.
As the 2027 elections approach, the President has reportedly declared that all is fair in politics, with victory being the ultimate objective. Such a declaration carries far-reaching implications. To his political foot soldiers, it could be interpreted as a licence to employ any means necessary to secure electoral victory.
Against this backdrop, allegations of opposition parties being denied access to venues in APC-controlled states become even more troubling. The desperation to retain power at all costs could also help explain the reported increase in politically motivated violence.
Recently, an NDC town hall meeting in Lagos was reportedly disrupted by suspected APC supporters. Similar attacks have been alleged in Benue, Edo, Ebonyi, Cross River, Delta and Enugu states. Reports of fatalities in Delta, Enugu and Ebonyi make the situation even more disturbing.
For a country that has practised uninterrupted democratic governance for 27 years, such developments are deeply unfortunate. They represent a dangerous departure from the principles and values that should define a democratic society.
Election periods should be opportunities for the exchange of ideas, the contestation of policies and the interplay of logic and reason. Elections are, after all, celebrations of democracy. Abraham Lincoln, the 16th President of the United States, captured its essence when he described democracy as government of the people, by the people and for the people.
It is this people-centred character that distinguishes democracy from other forms of government. A political system stripped of the people’s participation and consent is fundamentally an aberration.
There should be no misunderstanding about this: democracy does not automatically guarantee the emergence of good leaders, nor does it ensure good governance. However, it gives citizens a voice in determining how they are governed and guarantees them the freedom to choose their leaders and participate in the affairs of the state.
Once the people are removed from the equation, what remains can hardly be described as democracy, no matter how benevolent those in power may appear.
When governors, many of whom have allegedly performed poorly in their respective states, assure President Tinubu that they will deliver millions of votes for him in the January 16, 2027 presidential election, an important question arises: Do these governors genuinely have the mandate of their people to make such promises?
Peter Obi of the NDC has repeatedly raised this question, but convincing answers are yet to emerge. The governors may be making such assurances to please the President, but whether they can translate those promises into actual votes remains a matter for the electorate to decide.
The reality is that Nigerians are grappling with hunger, economic hardship and declining purchasing power. Many have also been displaced from their homes by insecurity, while the rising cost of living continues to erode their ability to meet basic needs.
Against this background, it is difficult to assume that citizens would willingly endorse another four years of the same policies without demanding explanations, accountability and credible alternatives.
This perhaps explains why substantive policy debates should be central to Tinubu’s re-election campaign. Nigerians deserve to know what the President intends to do differently, how he plans to address the country’s economic challenges, tackle insecurity, create jobs and improve living conditions.
Campaigns should not be reduced to insults, political intimidation, threats and questionable promises of electoral victories by governors. They should be platforms for presenting ideas, defending policies and persuading citizens through credible programmes.
Ultimately, elections are not won through noise, intimidation or inflammatory rhetoric alone. They are contests of ideas, vision, credibility and public trust.
A President seeking another mandate must be prepared to subject his record and proposals to public scrutiny. Anything short of that risks reducing the 2027 electoral contest to a hollow exercise in political propaganda, devoid of the substance and democratic engagement Nigerians deserve.
Emeka Alex Duru, PhD, is the Editor of TheNiche Online Newspapers, Lagos.